26. Taylor Russell – Waves [35/4]
27. Fatma Mohamed – In Fabric [34/3]
28. Tory Kittles – Dragged Across Concrete [32/4]
29. Leonardo Sbaraglia – Pain and Glory [29/4]
30. Scarlett Johansson – Jojo Rabbit [29/3]
31 (tie). Eric Bogosian – Uncut Gems [28/4]
31 (tie). Julia Butters – Once Upon a Time in Hollywood [28/4]
31 (tie). Martin Lawrence – The Beach Bum [28/4]
34 (tie). Jennifer Carpenter – Dragged Across Concrete [28/3]
34 (tie). Asier Exteandia – Pain and Glory [28/3]
36. Timothée Chalamet – Little Women [27/3]
37. Bill Camp – Dark Waters [26/3]
38. Juliette Binoche – High Life [25/3]
39. Ray Liotta – Marriage Story [24/3]
40. William Michael Payne – The Plagiarists [22/2]
41. Idina Menzel – Uncut Gems [21/3]
42. Tilda Swinton – The Souvenir [21/2]
43 (tie). Lakeith Stanfield – Uncut Gems [20.5/2]
43 (tie). Lorraine Toussaint – Fast Color [20.5/2]
45. Valerie Pachner – A Hidden Life [20/3]
46. Franz Rogowski – A Hidden Life [20/2]
47 (tie). Tim Heidecker – Us [18/2]
47 (tie). Mia Wasikowska – Piercing [18/2]
49. Elisabeth Moss – Us [17.5/2]
50. Kathy Bates – Richard Jewell [17/2]
51. Laura Dern – Little Women [16/2]
52 (tie). Winston Duke – Us [14/2]
52 (tie). Tom Hanks – A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood [14/2]
52 (tie). Lee Jeon-eun – Parasite [14/2]
55. Gregg Turkington – Mister America [14/1]
56. Mia Goth – High Life [13/2]
57 (tie). Adriana Asti – Pasolini [13/1]
57 (tie). Noah Galvin – Booksmart [13/1]
57 (tie). Eva Green – Dumbo [13/1]
57 (tie). Terri Parks – Mister America [13/1]
57 (tie). June Diane Raphael – Long Shot [13/1]
57 (tie). Keith Williams Richards – Uncut Gems [13/1]
63 (tie). Zoey Deutch – Double Tap [12/1]
63 (tie). Andre Hyland – Relaxer [12/1]
63 (tie). Sebastian Koch – Never Look Away [12/1]
63 (tie). Sonja Sohn – High Flying Bird [12/1]
63 (tie). Shahadi Wright Joseph – Us [12/1]
68. Ian McKellen – Cats [11/2]

The following performances received one vote apiece:
Farah Bala – High Flying Bird
Alec Baldwin – Motherless Brooklyn
Paula Beer – Transit
Zazie Beetz – High Flying Bird
Annette Bening – The Report
Halle Berry – John Wick Ch. 3: Parabellum
Mia Broderick – To Dust
Danielle Brooks – Clemency
Sterling K. Brown – Waves
Alfredo Castro – Rojo
Dean-Charles Chapman – 1917
Sam Claflin – The Nightingale
Kit Connor – Little Joe
Penélope Cruz – Pain and Glory
Ricardo Darín – Everybody Knows
Jeffrey Donovan – Villains
Bill Duke – High Flying Bird
Chris Evans – Knives Out
Kevin Garnett – Uncut Gems
Skyler Gisondo – Booksmart
Jeff Goldblum – The Mountain
Stephen Graham – The Irishman
Mark Hamill – Child’s Play
Linda Hamilton – Terminator: Dark Fate
Jon Hamm – Lucy in the Sky
Lucas Hedges – Waves
Aldis Hodge – Clemency
Bryce Dallas Howard – Rocketman
Jang Hye-jin – Parasite
Marianne Jean-Baptiste – In Fabric
Martha Kelly – Marriage Story
Lee Sun-kyun – Parasite
Tracy Letts – Ford v Ferrari
Juliette Lewis – Ma
Liao Fan – Ash Is Purest White
Dawn Luebbe – Greener Grass
Tzi Ma – The Farewell
Vincent Macgaigne – Non-Fiction
James McAvoy – Glass
Thomas Harcourt McKenzie – Jojo Rabbit
Ian McShane – John Wick Ch. 3: Parabellum
Julianne Moore – After the Wedding
Bill Murray – The Dead Don’t Die
Anna Paquin – The Irishman
Robert Pattinson – The King
Sarah Paulson – Glass
Wendell Pierce – Clemency
Denis Podalydès – Sorry Angel
Bill Pullman – Dark Waters
Gayle Rankin – Her Smell
Sam Rockwell – Jojo Rabbit
Sam Rockwell – Richard Jewell
Arnold Schwarzenegger – Terminator: Dark Fate
Andrew Scott – 1917
Chris Sullivan – I Trapped the Devil
Marisa Tomei – Frankie
Wang Yuwen – An Elephant Sitting Still
Emma Watson – Little Women
Curtis Webster – Mister America
Merritt Wever – Marriage Story